SOFTWARE COMPARISONS

Deputy vs Tanda: which one suits you (Australia)

Updated 8 November 2026•8 min read

Steve Harris

Written by

Steve Harris

Which one suits you

Deputy suits businesses where building the roster and the staff app are the daily job; Tanda suits those focused on what happens after the shift. That is what our hands-on reviews of both found.

Deputy is stronger where the roster and the phone are the job: site-based scheduling with demand forecasting and auto-scheduling, and a staff app built around shifts, swaps and clocking on. Tanda is stronger on what happens after the shift: reporting grouped into named categories, and a timesheet approval screen that gates each shift on named compliance checks before it is payroll-ready. Time tracking is close.

Read the full workings in our Deputy review and Tanda review. Like all our head-to-head comparisons, this page carries no scores; those belong to the individual reviews.


Where the gap is widest

Four areas separate them in our testing. Two favour Deputy, two favour Tanda, and they split cleanly along the line between building a roster and closing one out.

Rostering: Deputy ahead

Deputy's strongest suit. Our review found site-based scheduling with demand forecasting, auto-scheduling and multiple roster views. Tanda's roster is functional rather than exceptional — see the rostering section of our Tanda review.

Mobile apps: Deputy ahead

The area our Deputy review rated most highly. If your staff interact with the roster mainly through a phone — swapping shifts, clocking on, checking next week — this is the gap most likely to show up day to day. See our assessment of Deputy's apps.

Reporting: Tanda ahead

Tanda's clearest advantage, and it matches what the interface shows: reports grouped into named categories with filters, rather than a smaller fixed set. See the reporting section of our Tanda review.

Customer ratings: Tanda ahead

A different kind of evidence from our own testing: public review platforms. Read on 8 November 2026, Tanda rated 4.4 on the Xero App Store (52 reviews) and Capterra AU (111), and 4.8 on G2 (62); Deputy rated 3.9 on the Xero App Store (148), 4.6 on Capterra AU (775) and 4.5 on G2 (943).


What the two products look like

Screenshots from our own trial accounts, not vendor marketing renders — Deputy captured December 2025, Tanda January 2026. They show where each tool puts the same job, which is usually more telling than a feature table. Both vendors ship changes continuously, so treat these as a record of what we saw on those dates rather than a guarantee of what a trial shows today.

Building the roster

Both use a grid, but they orient it differently: Deputy runs staff down the side, Tanda groups by team and surfaces running hours and cost in the left rail.

Deputy weekly schedule view showing staff shifts across the week
Deputy's weekly roster view.
Tanda weekly roster grid grouped by team showing shifts from Monday to Sunday
Tanda's roster in stacked view, grouped by team, with total hours, cost and shift count in the left rail.

Turning approved time into pay

Two halves of the same job: Deputy assembles payslips in a pay run, Tanda gates approval on per-shift compliance checks.

Deputy pay run screen showing a weekly payslip with hours, super and leave balances
Deputy's pay run, building a weekly payslip. Totals read zero because this is a demo account.
Tanda timesheet approval screen showing shift details with compliance checks
Tanda's timesheet approval, with per-shift compliance checks.

Award interpretation setup

Both vendors state that they interpret modern awards. What differs is how much of the rule set you configure yourself.

Deputy award interpretation settings for Australian pay rates
Deputy's award interpretation settings.
Tanda award rule setup screen showing base hourly rate configuration
Tanda's award rule setup, configuring a base hourly rate.

What each vendor publishes

Each row states what the vendor puts on a public page, separate from our own testing above. A question mark means we could not confirm it from a public source; it is not a claim that the capability is missing.

  Deputy Tanda
Pricing model Three per-user tiers (Lite/Core/Pro) plus four paid add-ons, priced separately One bundled per-user price covering HR, payroll and workforce management; individual modules on request
Published entry price Lite $6.75 per user/month on an annual plan, $7.50 billed monthly; AUD excl GST $12.80 per user/month +GST (All in One)
Minimum spend AUD $30 per month per invoice on monthly Lite, Core and Pro No minimum spend stated on the public pricing page
Native payroll in the base price Payroll is a paid add-on at $5 per user/month on top of the plan Payroll is named as part of the bundled price
Annual billing discount Deputy states "Save 10% annually" against its add-ons Not stated on the public pricing page
Enterprise tier An Enterprise tier is listed alongside Lite/Core/Pro Not named on the public pricing page; module pricing is "on request"

Sources: Deputy AU pricing and Tanda pricing pages, read 8 November 2026.


Pricing

The clearest difference here is not a feature, it is the shape of the bill. Deputy sells a core platform and prices payroll, HR, messaging and analytics separately. Tanda sells one bundle. That makes the headline prices misleading in opposite directions. Every figure below is quoted from the vendor's own published pricing page, read on 8 November 2026.

Deputy logo

Deputy

Per user per month, AUD excl GST, on an annual plan or billed monthly

Lite $6.75 annual · $7.50 monthly

Everything you need to get started with scheduling and time tracking

Core $8.75 annual · $9.75 monthly

Advanced tools to streamline operations and boost productivity

Pro $13 annual · $14.50 monthly

Complete control with powerful automation, insights, & priority support

Add-ons, priced on top

  • Payroll $5
  • HR $3.50
  • Messaging+ $2.75
  • Analytics+ $2

Minimum monthly spend of AUD $30 per invoice on monthly Lite, Core and Pro.

Deputy's AU pricing page
Tanda logo

Tanda

Per user per month, +GST

All in One $12.80

HR + payroll + workforce management in one price

Tanda invites you to request individual module pricing rather than publishing per-module rates.

Tanda's pricing page

Reading the price difference

Deputy's entry price is well under Tanda's. That comparison only holds if you want rostering and time tracking and nothing else, because Tanda's figure already includes payroll and HR.

The same shopping basket, using each vendor's published rates

  • Rostering and time tracking only — Deputy Lite $6.75 on an annual plan or $7.50 billed monthly. Tanda does not publish a workforce-management-only rate; you would need to request module pricing.
  • Add payroll and HR — Deputy's All-in-One bundle (Core + Payroll + HR) = $13.95 on an annual plan or $15.50 billed monthly. Tanda All in One = $12.80. Both pre-tax, per user per month.

Deputy's $30 monthly invoice minimum also matters below about four users, where it sets the bill regardless of the per-user rate.


Xero App Store ratings

Public, dated and specific to the Australian Xero marketplace, a different signal from our own testing above.

Deputy

3.9/5 (148 reviews)

Tanda

4.4/5 (52 reviews)


What we could not verify

Comparison pages usually assert far more than their author can actually check. Here is what we deliberately did not claim, and why.

  • Which is stronger is our judgement, not the vendors'. It comes from our own hands-on testing. A business that weights reporting over rostering would rank these two differently on exactly the same findings.
  • Award interpretation depth. How each product applies modern award rules sits in help-centre documentation. Both help centres return HTTP 403 to non-browser clients, so we could not read them and have made no claim either way.
  • Tanda's module pricing. Only the All in One price is published; per-module rates are quoted on request, so a module-level comparison is not possible from public sources.
  • Implementation, onboarding and contract terms. Not measurable from published material.

Where RosterElf fits

We build RosterElf, so treat this section as what it is. If you are weighing Deputy against Tanda, the third option worth a look is a platform built around Australian award interpretation with a single per-employee price and no add-on ladder.

See Deputy vs RosterElf and Tanda vs RosterElf, our Deputy review and Tanda review, Tanda vs Employment Hero, or the best rostering software in Australia guide.

Our review methodology

Learn how we evaluate workforce management platforms through hands-on testing and verified user feedback.

Feature comparisons are checked against each vendor's public documentation at the time of writing. Assessments of usability, fit and value are our reviewers' opinions, not statements of fact, and products change often. We'd encourage you to trial both platforms and judge for yourself. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.

FAQ

Deputy vs Tanda: frequently asked questions

  • In our hands-on testing Deputy was stronger where the roster itself is the job: building rosters and the staff mobile app. Tanda was stronger after the shift: reporting, and compliance checks on each timesheet before it reaches payroll. Time tracking was close. Which matters more is a judgement about your business, not a fact about the products.
  • Rostering and mobile. Those were the two areas our Deputy review rated most highly: site-based scheduling with demand forecasting and auto-scheduling, and a staff app that handles shifts, swaps and clocking on. If managers build the roster daily and staff live in the app, that is where Deputy earns its place on a shortlist.
  • Reporting and the compliance checks around timesheets. Our Tanda review found reports grouped into named categories with filters, and a timesheet approval screen that gates each shift on a set of named checks before it is payroll-ready. Tanda also rates well with its customers: 4.4 on the Xero App Store and Capterra AU, and 4.8 on G2 (read 8 Nov 2026).

Start your free 15-day RosterElf trial today

Join 30,000+ workplaces using RosterElf to simplify rostering, payroll and HR.

Start trial Book a demo
4.6 stars from 323 reviews on Google, Xero and G2
100+ countries30,000+ workplaces