Software comparisons / Australia

Tanda 7.6/10
Employment Hero 6.2/10

Overall scores from our individual reviews · RosterElf editorial assessment · How we score

Tanda vs Employment Hero: Which is better for Australian businesses?

Workforce-first or HR-first? Compare Australian award pay rules, rostering, time and attendance, payroll, HR and pricing to see which platform suits your team.

Steve Harris Steve Harris Workforce Management and HR Strategy Expert
20 min read

Quick verdict

Choose Tanda if…

  • time and attendance and timesheet approval are the jobs you most need done well
  • you want award templates applied to timesheets while payroll stays in Xero or MYOB
  • you want labour cost visible while you roster

Consider: the package for a business keeping Xero or MYOB payroll is priced by quote, there was no self-serve trial when we tested, and support runs on AEST hours.

Choose Employment Hero if…

  • HR administration is your main job: records, contracts, policies and onboarding
  • you want Australian contract and policy templates built in
  • you want published prices you can calculate before you talk to sales

Consider: rostering and chat are paid add-ons, award costing needs its payroll, and support was the weakest part of our test.

Tanda scores higher overall in our editorial reviews (7.6 vs 6.2), but neither product suits every business.

Tanda is the better starting point for shift-based teams whose week is spent on rosters, clock-ins and timesheet checks. Time and attendance was the strongest area of our Tanda review, its approval screen shows compliance and wage-cost variance in one place, and its award templates work without Tanda Payroll. Its weakness is buying it, because only the payroll-inclusive bundle has a public price.

Employment Hero is the better starting point when HR is the bigger job than the roster. Its HR tools were the strongest area of our review, with rostering, time and attendance and chat added on top of an HR plan. Award-costed timesheets are tied to its own payroll.

Both send approved timesheets to Xero; only Tanda applies award pay rules without its own payroll.

Read the full Tanda review and Employment Hero review for the hands-on detail behind each point.

Our expert ratings

RosterElf editorial assessment. These are our reviewers' scores out of 10, taken unchanged from our Tanda review and Employment Hero review. They are not customer star ratings: Google and Xero App Store ratings are shown separately in the customer reviews section.

Tanda scores higher overall in our reviews (7.6 vs 6.2). A higher score doesn't make it the right choice for every business; the sections below show where each one is stronger.

Our editorial overall and category scores for Tanda and Employment Hero, out of 10
Category Weight Tanda Employment Hero Comparison
Overall 100% 7.6 6.2 Tanda higher
Ease of use 20% 7.7 6.5 Tanda higher
Rostering 15% 7.5 7.0 Tanda higher
Support 15% 6.9 4.0 Tanda higher
Time & attendance 10% 8.5 6.5 Tanda higher
Payroll 10% 7.6 Not scored Not compared
HR & compliance 10% 7.4 9.0 Employment Hero higher
Pricing 10% 7.1 4.0 Tanda higher
Mobile 4% 7.6 6.5 Tanda higher
Communication 2% 7.9 5.5 Tanda higher
Reporting 2% 8.3 7.5 Tanda higher
Security 2% 8.2 8.5 Employment Hero higher

Each overall is the weighted average of the 11 category scores, using the weights shown ; Employment Hero's overall is based on the 90% of the weight scored so far (payroll not scored yet), with the remaining weights rescaled. Scores within 0.2 of each other are shown as broadly comparable. See our review methodology.

Who are Tanda & Employment Hero?

Tanda

Tanda is a Brisbane-based workforce management company, founded in 2012. It sells three modules: Workforce Management (rostering, time and attendance and award interpretation), HR, and Tanda Payroll. HR works without Tanda Payroll, so a business keeping Xero or MYOB can buy Workforce Management with HR. Tanda's onboarding is sales-led, and its public pricing shows a bundle of all three modules, with individual modules priced on request.

Read our Tanda review

Employment Hero

Employment Hero is an Australian HR, payroll and recruitment platform, founded in 2014 and headquartered in Sydney, also operating in New Zealand, the UK, Singapore and Malaysia. It sells HR plans (HR Essentials, HR Engage and HR Elite) priced per employee, with Payroll as a separate plan. Rostering & Time and Attendance and Chat are paid add-ons. Staff use the Employment Hero Work app.

Read our Employment Hero review

Tanda vs Employment Hero pricing: What will you actually pay?

Prices are in AUD, excluding GST, on monthly billing. Tanda publishes one bundle that includes its payroll module and prices everything else by quote. Employment Hero charges per employee for an HR plan, with rostering and chat as add-ons.

Tanda Tanda pricing page: the All-in-one bundle per user per month plus GST, with Request pricing buttons for each module
Tanda's pricing page: the All-in-one bundle at A$12.80 + GST, which includes Tanda Payroll; module prices on request. No Workforce Management + HR price is shown. Captured November 2026.
Employment Hero Employment Hero pricing page showing the HR Essentials, HR Engage, HR Elite and Employment Unlimited plans, with the Chat and Rostering add-ons
Employment Hero's pricing page: HR plans per employee a month, with Chat and Rostering & Time and Attendance as add-ons. Captured 21 November 2026.

Tanda pricing, bundles and custom quotes

Tanda packagePriceWhat it covers
All-in-one bundle A$12.80 + GST* per user a month; billing term not stated Workforce Management, HR and Tanda Payroll
Workforce Management + HR Custom quote* — request a quote Rostering, time and attendance, award interpretation and HR, keeping payroll in Xero or MYOB
Individual modules Custom quote* Workforce Management, HR or Payroll on their own

* Tanda publishes one price: A$12.80 + GST per user a month for a bundle of Workforce Management, HR and Tanda Payroll, with no billing term stated. Other packages, including Workforce Management + HR for businesses keeping Xero or MYOB payroll, show “Request pricing”, so their price comes from Tanda’s sales team.

For context only: a 14 December 2025 review by Connecteam (a competitor of Tanda) recorded about A$14 per user a month for Workforce Management + HR, excluding payroll, in a trial for a 50-worker hospitality business, with GST treatment not stated. It is not a current quote, and the author notes the same costs may not apply to every account.

Employment Hero pricing, plans and add-ons

Employment Hero plan or add-onPriceMinimum
HR EssentialsA$11 per employee a month10 employees
HR EngageA$15 per employee a month10 employees
HR Elite, Employment UnlimitedCustom pricedOn quote
PayrollA$10 per employee a month10 employees
Rostering & Time and Attendance (add-on)A$5 per employee a monthA$50 a month
Chat (add-on)A$2.50 per employee a monthA$25 a month

Employment Hero bills on the higher of your contracted or billable employees, with a 10-employee minimum on its plans. Rostering and Chat are included only in the custom-priced Employment Unlimited. It also sells Managed Payroll (A$21 per employee, minimum A$420 a month) and HR Advisory (A$15 per employee, minimum A$300 a month). We found no published annual-billing discount.

What 20 employees would cost under comparable assumptions

The scenario: 20 staff, rostering, time and attendance, payroll-ready timesheets, basic HR and staff messaging, with payroll staying in Xero or MYOB. No native payroll subscription is included.

TandaEmployment Hero
Package Workforce Management + HR HR Essentials + Rostering & Time and Attendance + Chat
Price basis Custom quote* A$11 + A$5 + A$2.50 = A$18.50 per employee a month
20 employees a month Custom quote* (historical indication about A$280, from the 14 December 2025 observation above) A$18.50 × 20 = A$370
Basis No current published price Published AUD prices, monthly billing, excluding GST; plan minimums met at 20

* Tanda prices Workforce Management + HR on request; see the note under the Tanda pricing table above.

Employment Hero's help guides list HR Essentials as eligible for Xero and MYOB integrations and approved timesheet upload; confirm this in writing for your account. With 5 staff, its package still bills 10 employees on HR Essentials and the add-on minimums, so it comes to A$185 a month.

If payroll moves into the platform too

Tanda's published bundle, A$12.80 + GST* per user a month, includes Workforce Management, HR and Tanda Payroll: A$256 a month for 20 staff. Employment Hero HR Essentials with Payroll, Rostering & Time and Attendance and Chat comes to A$570 a month. On published prices, Tanda's bundle is the lower figure.

* Tanda’s advertised price for its Workforce Management, HR and Tanda Payroll bundle. No billing term, minimum or eligibility is stated beside it, and its other packages are priced on request through Tanda’s sales team, so confirm the price for your headcount in writing.

Which offers better value for the required workflow

Employment Hero is easier to cost: you can work out a monthly bill from its pricing page. Tanda may be cheaper or dearer for the same workflow without payroll; there is no published figure to say.

Ask Tanda for a written quote for Workforce Management with HR, including any onboarding fee, minimum and billing term, and set it against the Employment Hero total above.

Price isn't the whole picture: Tanda's package includes award templates applied without its payroll, while Employment Hero's award costing needs its payroll. Employment Hero's HR plan gives you more HR for the money, including Australian contract and policy templates.

What do customers say about Tanda and Employment Hero?

Ratings from Google Reviews and the Xero App Store, shown separately by platform and never averaged together. These are customer ratings, not our editorial assessment.

Tanda

Xero App Store

4.4/5

52 reviews · snapshot 18 November 2026 · View listing

Google Reviews

No reviews found

Tanda has no Google reviews we could find, checked 21 November 2026.

Employment Hero

Xero App Store (Employment Hero HR)

3.2/5

20 reviews · snapshot 18 November 2026 · View listing

Google Reviews

Not verified

No approved snapshot of a Google rating for Employment Hero yet.

Tanda had no Google reviews we could find when we checked on 21 November 2026. We don't yet have an approved snapshot of a Google rating for Employment Hero, so it is shown as not verified. Both vendors have reviews on commercial software review marketplaces; we don't use those in our comparisons, for the reasons in the note below.

On the Xero App Store, Tanda's rating is higher than Employment Hero HR's . The rating shown for Employment Hero is its HR listing; Employment Hero Payroll has a separate Xero listing, which we don't use here because payroll is outside the package compared.

Xero listings carry reviews from Xero users about the integration and the product as a whole, not about the exact package compared on this page. We haven't published a theme analysis of the underlying reviews, so we don't summarise what reviewers praise or criticise here.

We use Google Reviews and the Xero App Store as our primary third-party customer-feedback sources for these comparisons. We do not use ratings from commercial software review marketplaces in our scoring. We select these sources under a policy designed to reduce reliance on incentivised reviews; however, we cannot independently guarantee that every individual review is genuine or free from incentives. Ratings, review counts and snapshot dates are shown separately by platform.

Tanda vs Employment Hero feature comparison

Twelve headline capabilities from our 46-row feature audit, as at 18 November 2026, 5:27 pm AWST. Tanda is assessed as Workforce Management with HR, without Tanda Payroll; Employment Hero as HR Essentials with Rostering & Time and Attendance and Chat, with payroll kept external.

  • Drag-and-drop roster builder

    Tanda Included

    Rosters grouped by team, with labour cost shown in the roster.

    Employment Hero Included

    In the Rostering & Time and Attendance add-on.

  • Shift swaps

    Tanda Limited

    One-to-one swaps only, off by default, in the mobile app.

    Employment Hero Included

    Shift bidding and swapping listed in the rostering add-on.

  • GPS clock-in / clock-out

    Tanda Included

    Off by default and enabled per team; geofence per location.

    Employment Hero Included

    Geofence for each work site in the Work app; no pin-drop location.

  • Photo capture on clock-in

    Tanda Included

    Photo at every clock-in; face matching is opt-in.

    Employment Hero Included

    Photo capture at app clock-in.

  • Manager timesheet approval

    Tanda Included

    Approval screen shows compliance checks and wage-cost variance.

    Employment Hero Included

    Admins approve timesheets before they go to payroll.

  • Full award interpretation

    Tanda Included

    Tanda-maintained templates for common awards; others built as custom rules.

    Employment Hero Add-on required

    Award-costed timesheets need Employment Hero Payroll (+A$10 per employee); without it, shifts are costed from hourly rates.

  • Xero Payroll (AU) transfer

    Tanda Included

    Approved timesheets export to Xero.

    Employment Hero Included

    Approved timesheets upload to Xero Payroll as drafts, then you approve them in Xero.

  • MYOB transfer

    Tanda Included

    Direct to AccountRight Live; MYOB Business not confirmed.

    Employment Hero Limited

    AccountRight timesheets don't sync: import a timesheet CSV. Employee details and leave do sync.

  • Direct & group messaging

    Tanda Included

    One-to-one and group chats, switched on in settings.

    Employment Hero Included

    Chat add-on (+A$2.50 per employee, minimum A$25 a month); groups up to 10 people.

  • Offline clock-ins

    Tanda Limited

    The tablet time clock queues clock-ins offline; the mobile app needs a connection.

    Employment Hero Not verified

    Offline behaviour not established.

  • HR with your existing payroll

    Tanda Included

    HR module priced by quote; Tanda Payroll not needed.

    Employment Hero Included

    HR plans connect to Xero and MYOB; Employment Hero Payroll not needed.

  • Custom report filters

    Tanda Included

    Filters by team, location, role, award tag and qualification; no report builder.

    Employment Hero Add-on required

    Custom reports need HR Elite or Employment Unlimited, both custom priced.

Statuses: Included, Limited (exists with a material restriction), Add-on required, Not available, and Not verified (we found no vendor documentation for it, which is not the same as the product lacking it). Both platforms change often; check the vendor before you buy.

Rostering

Rostering is part of Tanda's core Workforce Management module. In Employment Hero it is the Rostering & Time and Attendance add-on, bought on top of an HR plan.

Tanda Tanda weekly roster grouped by team with weather icons and a labour cost summary
Tanda roster grouped by team, with weather icons and a labour cost summary. Captured January 2026.
Employment Hero Employment Hero roster management, weekly by work site, with shift hours, shift cost and budget fields above the roster
Employment Hero roster management, weekly by work site, with shift hours, shift cost and budget fields above the roster. Captured 21 November 2026.

Building and publishing rosters

Tanda groups the roster by team rather than by site. Its AI auto-build gave little guidance in our test, and moving a staff member to another team took five steps outside the roster. Employment Hero shows the roster by work site, weekly, two-weekly or four-weekly, with bulk shifts and templates that carry cost, hours and staff counts.

Forecasting and labour-cost controls

Tanda shows hours and wage cost alongside the roster as you build it. Employment Hero's add-on lists budgeting and real-time labour costs; with payroll kept in Xero or MYOB, shifts are costed from employee hourly rates rather than award rules.

Staff availability, shift swaps and changes

Tanda's shift swaps are one-to-one, switched off by default and handled in the mobile app. Employment Hero's add-on lists shift bidding and swapping.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • We liked seeing total hours, shifts and wage cost beside the roster, though the breakdown is high-level and sales data lives elsewhere.
  • Staff are locked to their team: moving someone took five steps outside the roster, which makes last-minute cover cumbersome.
  • Roster breaks were added by hand, were hard to remove and could not be bulk-edited, and some AI actions returned errors without explanation.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • Each shift showed hours, breaks and cost; bulk shifts repeated a shift across several days, and templates carried cost, hours and staff counts.
  • There is no staff list view, only by work site and position, and filtering by staff or position is limited.
  • We did not find a live labour budget in our trial; budgeting is now listed in the add-on.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Rostering score: Tanda 7.5/10 Employment Hero 7.0/10 Tanda scores higher

Our pick for rostering: Tanda, for teams where the roster is the daily job: it scored higher in our reviews and keeps wage cost in view as you build. Its friction sits in everyday edits (team-locked staff, manual roster breaks), so trial it with your real roster. Employment Hero's add-on suits simple, steady rosters built by work site.

Time & attendance

Both include app clock-in with geofences and photo capture, and manager timesheet approval. The difference is in where settings apply, offline use and what the approval screen shows.

Tanda Tanda geofencing settings with a configurable login radius and business hours per location
Tanda geofencing settings with a login radius and business hours per location. Captured January 2026.
Employment Hero Employment Hero clock-in settings with app clock-in, photo capture and geofencing switched on for the whole business
Employment Hero clock-in settings: app clock-in, photo capture and geofencing, switched on for the whole business, with a geofence for each work site. Captured 21 November 2026.

Employee clock-in and clock-out

Tanda uses the mobile app, which is off by default and enabled per team, and a tablet Time Clock app. Employment Hero staff clock in through the Employment Hero Work app, and Hero Time Clock runs on a kiosk or shared device.

Location and identity controls

Tanda takes a photo at every clock-in, offers face matching as an opt-in, and sets a geofence per location. Employment Hero captures a photo at app clock-in and sets a geofence for each work site, with a choice of what happens when someone clocks out outside it; its clock-in settings apply to the whole business.

Offline use: Tanda's tablet time clock queues clock-ins, while its mobile app needs a connection. We haven't established how Employment Hero behaves offline.

Breaks, exceptions and approvals

Both require approval before timesheets go to payroll. Tanda's approval screen puts compliance checks, wage cost and variance beside each timesheet. Employment Hero approves daily timesheets, which an admin then uploads to Xero.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • Our reviewer called time and attendance arguably Tanda's core strength.
  • Geofences are set per location on a map, and colour-coded icons on each timesheet show whether a clock-in was inside the radius.
  • Contextual help beside the location setup screens reduced setup friction; the trade-offs we noted were photo checks slowing clock-in and geofences relying on correct addresses.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • App clock-in with photo capture, a geofence for each work site, and a choice of what happens when someone clocks out outside the geofence.
  • There is no pin-drop location for a precise clock-in point.
  • Clock-in settings applied to the whole business, not per site. We did not test the Hero Time Clock kiosk.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Time & attendance score: Tanda 8.5/10 Employment Hero 6.5/10 Tanda scores higher

Our pick for time and attendance: Tanda, clearly. Time and attendance was the strongest area of our Tanda review, with per-location geofences and more evidence on each clock-in for approvers. Employment Hero works for single-site teams; if you need different clock-in rules at different sites, test it closely.

Award interpretation

Award interpretation turns approved hours into pay lines under the right award. It is separate from sending timesheets to payroll, and separate from running payroll itself.

Tanda Tanda award rule setup with contextual hints for base hourly rates and applicability
Tanda award rule setup, with hints for base hourly rates and when a rule applies. Captured January 2026.
Employment Hero Employment Hero Classifications screen with a notice that classifications are managed through the payroll system, an Update From Payroll button, and award classifications with View Pay Rates
Employment Hero Classifications: award classifications are managed through your payroll system and pulled in with Update From Payroll. Captured 21 November 2026.

Supported Australian modern award rules

Tanda maintains templates for common awards, including rate updates, and builds other awards as custom rules. Employment Hero's Payroll plan includes award interpretation, and its rostering add-on lists award-based costing, which works only with Employment Hero Payroll connected.

Penalty rates, allowances and overtime

Tanda applies overtime and penalty rules to timesheets. With payroll kept in Xero or MYOB, Employment Hero's HR and rostering setup costs shifts from employee hourly rates; penalties and allowances are then worked out in your payroll system. Confirm edge cases in writing with Employment Hero.

Setup and limitations

In Tanda, awards outside its templates need custom rules set up and maintained by you or Tanda, and it doesn't need Tanda Payroll to calculate award pay. Employment Hero needs Employment Hero Payroll (A$10 per employee a month) for award-costed timesheets. Either way, the employer stays responsible for correct classifications, rates and pay.

What to test in a demo

Take a few casual employees working evenings, weekends and public holidays to both demos and ask each vendor to show how it handles:

  • Employee classifications and casual loadings
  • Saturday, Sunday and public holiday penalty rates
  • Overtime and minimum engagement rules
  • Unpaid and paid breaks
  • Allowances that apply to the employee’s duties
  • A timesheet correction before payroll approval, and what changes in the pay

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • Award compliance depends heavily on accurate configuration, and setting rules up meant moving across several menus.
  • We found limited high-level visibility of how rates were being applied across the business.
  • Tanda's link between clock-ins and award costing is where it sets itself apart, but complex awards need time to configure and test before going live.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • The Rostering & Time and Attendance add-on lists award-based costing, but award costing works only with Employment Hero Payroll connected.
  • In our trial, help articles pointed to an award library that was not in our account.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Section score: Not scored in our reviews

Our pick for award interpretation: Tanda, if payroll stays in Xero or MYOB: its award templates apply to timesheets without Tanda Payroll. Employment Hero ties award interpretation to Employment Hero Payroll, so it makes more sense if you plan to run payroll there. Neither review gives award interpretation its own score, and both need careful setup: test your award with your own pay data.

Payroll & integrations

Both send approved timesheets to external payroll, and both also sell their own payroll, which is outside the comparison package on this page.

StepTandaEmployment Hero
1. RosterTandaEmployment Hero Rostering add-on
2. Timesheet approvedTandaEmployment Hero
3. Award pay rules appliedTanda award templatesYour payroll system (hourly-rate costing in Employment Hero)
4. Pay run, payslips, STPXero or MYOBXero or MYOB

Xero workflow

Tanda exports approved timesheets to Xero. Employment Hero uploads approved daily timesheets to Xero Payroll as drafts: an admin clicks Upload to Xero, then approves them in Xero. Both are listed on the Xero App Store.

MYOB workflow

Tanda connects directly to MYOB AccountRight Live; we could not confirm a direct MYOB Business connection. With Employment Hero and MYOB AccountRight, employee details and leave sync but timesheets don't: you download a timesheet CSV and import it.

External versus native payroll

Tanda Payroll is one of Tanda's three modules and is included in its published bundle; we did not test it. Employment Hero's Payroll plan is A$10 per employee (with unlimited pay runs, tax calculations, award interpretation and payroll reporting), and Managed Payroll, where Employment Hero runs payroll for you, is A$21 per employee. If payroll stays in Xero or MYOB, you need neither.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • Tanda Payroll was not in our trial, so we could not test it end to end.
  • Even with Tanda Payroll, journals still have to be exported to Xero or MYOB, which can feel duplicated for businesses whose bookkeeper works in the accounting software.
  • Businesses keeping payroll in Xero or MYOB AccountRight avoid that step: approved timesheets go straight across.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • Payroll sits inside the same platform as HR.
  • We could not finish setting it up: the training videos in the Payroll Start Guide did not play, and support had no free booking slots, so setup stalled.
  • Because of that, our review leaves payroll unscored.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Payroll score: Not scored in our reviews

Our pick for payroll: Tanda, if payroll stays in Xero or MYOB AccountRight: approved timesheets go straight across, and it connects to AccountRight Live directly where Employment Hero needs a CSV import. Neither vendor's own payroll was tested end to end. If you want payroll in the platform, ask each for a live payroll demo with your own pay conditions.

Communication

Both include company announcements. Tanda includes chat in Workforce Management; Employment Hero sells staff chat as a paid add-on.

Tanda Tanda groups feed showing announcements and team posts
Tanda groups feed with announcements and team posts. Capture date not recorded.
Employment Hero Employment Hero recognition post naming a colleague and a company value, set to visible to everyone
Employment Hero recognition post: a shout-out tied to a company value, visible to everyone. Captured 21 November 2026.

Staff messaging and announcements

Tanda has groups, announcements with acknowledgements, polls, and one-to-one and group chats. Employment Hero's Chat add-on covers direct messages, groups and file sharing, and its Company Feed, shout-outs and recognitions handle announcements.

Plan limits

Employment Hero Chat is A$2.50 per employee a month, with a A$25 monthly minimum, and group chats of up to 10 people; it is included in the custom-priced Employment Unlimited. Without it, staff can comment on company feed posts but can't message each other.

Shift notifications

Tanda lets you choose the app, email or SMS when you publish a roster. Notifications are one-way alerts, not conversations.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • More depth than most rostering platforms: posts can carry polls, acknowledgements and visibility settings.
  • The layout is clean and the chat resembles familiar messaging apps, which helps adoption.
  • In our account, people had to be in a team before they could be added to a chat, and the advanced post settings add steps to a quick announcement.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • Direct messaging was not in the standard package: without the paid Work Chat add-on, staff could comment on company feed posts but not message managers or coworkers.
  • Work Chat group chats are limited to 10 people, which is restrictive for messaging a whole venue or department.
  • Even with Work Chat on, everyday conversations felt more complicated than necessary.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Communication score: Tanda 7.9/10 Employment Hero 5.5/10 Tanda scores higher

Our pick for communication: Tanda, clearly: announcements with polls and acknowledgements, and chat, without a separate messaging add-on. Test its team-based chat permissions if you often pull people from different teams into one conversation. With Employment Hero, budget for Chat and check the group size limit against your team.

Mobile apps

Both have iOS and Android apps for staff and managers. Tanda's app leans towards oversight; Employment Hero's Work app covers HR self-service as well as shifts.

Tanda Tanda mobile app roster view showing shift details with hours and cost summary
Tanda mobile roster view with shift details, hours and cost summary. Captured January 2026.
Employment Hero Employment Hero Work app screens: home, the Work hub, rosters with Copy shifts, and shift details
The Employment Hero Work app: home, the Work hub, rosters with Copy shifts, and shift details. Captured 21 November 2026.

Employee experience

Staff on both apps see their rosters and request leave. Tanda's swaps are one-to-one and app-only. Employment Hero Work has four sections (Work, Money, Career and Benefits), with payslips, documents and certifications on the phone.

Manager experience

Tanda managers see team metrics and approve timesheets, leave and unavailability, but deeper changes need the desktop. Employment Hero managers see rosters and shift details and can copy shifts.

Restrictions

Tanda's offline queueing is on the tablet time clock, not the mobile app; we haven't established Employment Hero's offline behaviour.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • Well suited to oversight: managers see hours, labour cost, sales and wage percentage while away from the desk.
  • Stronger at monitoring than acting; adjusting sites or positions needs the web browser.
  • Navigation felt menu-heavy, with overlapping sections, and took time to learn. Updates were infrequent.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • Payslips, leave requests, documents and certifications are on the phone, and managers get rosters, shift details and Copy shifts.
  • Menus are busy, with many features in a small space.
  • Money and perks features sat beside everyday work tasks.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Mobile score: Tanda 7.6/10 Employment Hero 6.5/10 Tanda scores higher

Our pick for mobile: Tanda, for managers who want hours, labour cost and wage percentage on the phone; deeper changes still need the browser. Employment Hero's Work app is broader, with pay, documents and perks, but we found it busier for everyday shift tasks.

HR tools

This is the biggest difference between the two. HR is a separate module beside Tanda's workforce management; it is Employment Hero's core product.

Tanda Tanda qualifications and compliance tracking
Tanda qualifications and compliance tracking. Capture date not recorded.
Employment Hero Employment Hero employee profile with tabs for employment records, pay, documents, performance, payslips and assets
Employment Hero employee profile with tabs for employment records, pay, documents, performance, payslips and assets. Captured 21 November 2026.

Employee records and documents

Tanda's HR Hub covers documents, qualifications with expiry alerts (an expired qualification can block rostering), forms, warning letters, incidents and surveys. Employment Hero HR Essentials covers leave, employee records, documents, onboarding and offboarding, policies and compliance tools, with a library of Australian contract and policy templates.

Onboarding and contracts

Tanda collects TFN and super details at onboarding; contract features mentioned in its demo were not visible in the account we reviewed. Employment Hero automates onboarding with e-signatures and checklists.

HR plan eligibility

Tanda's HR module is priced by quote, or included in the payroll bundle. Employment Hero HR Essentials is A$11 per employee; HR Engage (A$15) adds recruitment, expenses, performance management and learning, which aren't part of the package compared here.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • The HR Hub is broad (forms, warnings, training, incidents and surveys) and logically structured at a high level.
  • We found little in-product guidance, and no obvious way to create or upload a form in the Forms section.
  • Contract features mentioned in the demo were not visible in the account we reviewed, so full hands-on testing was limited.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • HR is where Employment Hero is strongest: detailed employee profiles hold records, pay, documents and performance in one place.
  • An extensive template library for Australian contracts and policies, and onboarding automated with e-signatures and checklists.
  • There is a lot to learn before the full suite pays off, and some features needed a higher plan.
Source: our Employment Hero review

HR & compliance score: Tanda 7.4/10 Employment Hero 9.0/10 Employment Hero scores higher

Our pick for HR: Employment Hero, clearly. If HR administration is your main job, it is the stronger platform, with Australian contract and policy templates built in. Tanda's HR Hub covers the compliance records shift-based teams need, such as qualifications, warnings and incidents, but gave little in-product guidance.

Reporting

Tanda centres on labour cost and attendance reports; Employment Hero on people and compliance reports.

Tanda Tanda reports dashboard with AI search and category filtering
Tanda reports dashboard with AI search and category filtering. Capture date not recorded.
Employment Hero Employment Hero reports grouped by category: people, compliance, time, development and more
Employment Hero reports grouped by category: people, compliance, time, development and more. Captured 21 November 2026.

Standard reports

Tanda's cost reports compare rostered cost with timesheet cost, and attendance reports track punctuality. Employment Hero has people, compliance, performance and recruitment reports, with roster, timesheet and live-view reports added by the rostering add-on.

Labour analytics

We could not verify an overtime or penalty report in either vendor's documentation, so ask before you rely on one; Tanda's cost reports show totals. We found no labour cost forecasting in Employment Hero.

Export and filtering

Tanda filters by team, location, role, award tag and qualification without an add-on, but has no report builder. Employment Hero's custom reports need HR Elite or Employment Unlimited, both custom priced.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • A broad library of ready-made reports, and filtering we rated one of Tanda's strongest areas.
  • Easy to start with: reports can be pinned and emailed without building anything.
  • Export formats are limited beyond the attendance CSV, and reports carry no description of what each one covers.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • Reports are well organised by category, with clear descriptions, and people and compliance reporting is strong.
  • Customisation and export options are limited.
  • There is no labour cost forecasting.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Reporting score: Tanda 8.3/10 Employment Hero 7.5/10 Tanda scores higher

Our pick for reporting: It depends on what you report on. Tanda, for labour cost and attendance, with filtering that needs no add-on; Employment Hero, for people and compliance reporting. Tanda scored higher in our reviews.

Security

These are the vendors' own published statements, recorded in our reviews. We did not test them independently.

ControlTandaEmployment Hero
Two-factor authenticationYesYes, every plan
Single sign-onOn requestHR Elite and Employment Unlimited (custom priced)
Role-based permissionsYesNot verified
Australian data hostingYesNot verified
EncryptionEncryption statedNot verified
CertificationsSOC 2 not publicly advertisedSOC 2 Type II (report dated October 2025)
Audit logsNot verifiedNot verified

Employment Hero publishes a public Trust Centre. "Not verified" means our review didn't record a statement on it, not that the control is missing. If your data must stay in Australia, ask Employment Hero where it is hosted; if SOC 2 matters to your procurement process, ask Tanda for its current assurance reports.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • We found Tanda's controls appropriate and reliable for most Australian businesses.
  • Certifications are less prominently published, so procurement-driven buyers may need to ask Tanda for assurance reports.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • We did not test security controls hands-on; this area is scored from what Employment Hero publishes.
  • A strong fit if you need certified security; single sign-on means a custom-priced plan.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Security score: Tanda 8.2/10 Employment Hero 8.5/10 Employment Hero scores higher

Our pick for security: Either, for most small and mid-sized businesses. Employment Hero, if your procurement process asks for SOC 2 evidence before you sign; ask it where it hosts your data. Tanda states Australian hosting; ask it for its current assurance reports.

Customer support

Channels and hours

Tanda supports customers in AEST business hours, with no after-hours support, which shortens the window for WA businesses. Employment Hero offers help-centre articles and chat support on every plan, with priority support in Employment Unlimited.

Getting started

Tanda had no self-serve trial when we tested: we registered interest, spoke with sales and were set up with a trial account close to a week later. Employment Hero offers implementation as a Managed or a Guided journey.

Help centre and escalation

Both run online help centres. Our Tanda support observations come from our January 2026 trial; our Employment Hero support observations come from one trial account in October 2026.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • Getting a trial took close to a week through sales, and the onboarding demo ended early with no clear plan afterwards.
  • The in-app help tool often struggled to return relevant answers, and on-screen guidance was sparse.
  • Support runs in AEST business hours only, which shortens the window for WA businesses.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • Help-centre articles and chat support were available, but there were no onboarding emails in the first two days of the trial.
  • Phone support asked for a Support PIN, with unclear steps to set one up, and onboarding support had no free booking slots.
  • Some help articles were out of date, and some videos did not play.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Support score: Tanda 6.9/10 Employment Hero 4.0/10 Tanda scores higher Employment Hero support tested October 2026

Our pick for support: Tanda, though neither start was smooth: it scored well ahead, but onboarding was sales-led and support runs on AEST hours. Support was the weakest part of our Employment Hero test. With either, agree your implementation support in writing before you sign.

Ease of use

What each review found when setting the product up and using it day to day.

AreaTandaEmployment Hero
InterfaceFunctional, but noticeably datedComprehensive, but overwhelming at first
Building rostersRelatively simple once set upBasic, and less intuitive than dedicated rostering tools
Initial configurationMore effort; some settings not obviousTime-consuming; we often needed the help guides
Hardest part in our testingInitial configuration and complex award rulesKnowing where to start in a very broad platform

Our Tanda review found it functional and reasonably easy to learn for everyday operations, but less intuitive when configuring the system or managing more advanced requirements. Our Employment Hero review found it comprehensive but overwhelming for a small shift-based business, with time-consuming setup and basic rostering.

Reviewer opinion

What our reviewers found

From our hands-on Tanda and Employment Hero reviews. These are our assessments, not vendor facts.

Tanda
  • Everyday tasks such as clocking in, viewing shifts, requesting leave and basic drag-and-drop rostering were straightforward once set up.
  • We found the interface noticeably dated, with some workflows needing more navigation than necessary.
  • Initial configuration, advanced settings and complex award rules were the hardest parts of our assessment.
Source: our Tanda review
Employment Hero
  • A very broad platform: knowing where to start was our biggest challenge, and much of it felt like more than a small shift-based business needs.
  • Even basic setup took longer than expected; we often needed the help guides, which were reasonably useful.
  • Rostering felt basic and less intuitive than dedicated rostering platforms.
Source: our Employment Hero review

Ease of use score: Tanda 7.7/10 Employment Hero 6.5/10 Tanda scores higher

Our pick for ease of use: Tanda, for everyday rostering and timesheets. Employment Hero suits businesses that want a broad HR platform and can give its setup time.

Best for: Tanda or Employment Hero by use case

If your business has…Lean towardsWhy
Complex timesheets to checkTandaCompliance checks, wage cost and variance on the approval screen.
HR administration as the main jobEmployment HeroDetailed employee records, Australian contract and policy templates, and onboarding with e-signatures.
Award pay rules with payroll in Xero or MYOBTandaAward templates applied without Tanda Payroll; Employment Hero's award costing needs Employment Hero Payroll.
HR and payroll in one productEitherTanda's bundle and Employment Hero's HR plus Payroll both put the two together. We tested neither payroll end to end, so ask for a live demo.
Hospitality venues with casual staffTandaClock-in evidence, award-costed timesheets and labour cost in the roster. Check weekend and public holiday penalties in the demo.
Healthcare and aged careEitherTanda can block rostering on an expired qualification; Employment Hero keeps deeper records. Check classifications and enterprise agreements in both.
Existing Xero payrollEitherBoth send approved timesheets to Xero.
Existing MYOB AccountRight payrollTandaDirect to AccountRight Live; Employment Hero timesheets reach AccountRight by CSV import.
A budget you need to know up frontEmployment HeroPublished prices; Tanda's comparable package is quote-only.
Fewer than 10 staffAsk bothEmployment Hero bills at least 10 employees; Tanda prices the package by quote.

Final verdict: Tanda or Employment Hero?

Tanda scores higher overall in our editorial reviews (7.6 vs 6.2). Tanda scored higher for ease of use, rostering, support, time and attendance, pricing, mobile, communication, and reporting ; Employment Hero scored higher for HR and compliance, and security. Which one suits you depends on whether the roster or HR is the bigger job.

Choose Tanda if the daily work is rostering, checking clock-ins and approving timesheets against award rules, and you want payroll to stay in Xero or MYOB. Its approval screen, filtered reports and tablet clock suit that work, and its award templates apply without Tanda Payroll.

Choose Employment Hero if HR is the bigger job: employee records, Australian contracts and policies, and onboarding. Its HR tools were the strongest area of our review, and it makes the most sense if you also plan to run payroll there, because that is where its award interpretation sits.

The catch with Tanda is buying it: the package a Xero or MYOB business needs is quote-only, onboarding is sales-led and support runs on AEST business hours. The catch with Employment Hero is rostering depth and support: its rostering is an add-on we found suited to simple, steady rosters, and support was the weakest part of our test.

Get Tanda's quote in writing and set it against the Employment Hero total before you decide. MYOB AccountRight users should note that Employment Hero timesheets need a CSV import.

Full detail: Tanda review · Employment Hero review.

RosterElf alternative

RosterElf publishes this comparison and sells competing software, so we keep it out of the scores and verdict above. If neither Tanda nor Employment Hero fits, RosterElf focuses on rostering, time and attendance, award-based labour costs and payroll-ready timesheets for Australian businesses. It does not run payroll itself: approved timesheets go to Xero or MYOB payroll.

Research & methodology

What we tested hands-on

For Tanda we set up a trial account, built rosters, tested award settings and reviewed the Xero integration, with screenshots from January 2026; we did not test Tanda Payroll. For Employment Hero we used a trial account for a week in December 2025: we built rosters, set clock-in rules, worked through HR records, templates and onboarding, and tried to set up payroll. Our Employment Hero support observations are dated October 2026, and its screenshots on this page are dated 21 November 2026.

This comparison draws on those reviews; it is not a fresh round of testing. Each "What our reviewers found" box repeats only what those two reviews found, links to the review section it comes from, and is kept apart from the verified product facts above it.

How the scores work

The scores on this page are our editorial assessments, out of 10, copied unchanged from our Tanda and Employment Hero reviews through one shared data source, so this page can't disagree with them. We don't rescore for a comparison. Scores within 0.2 of each other are treated as broadly comparable. Our Employment Hero review doesn't score payroll, because we couldn't finish setting it up, so its overall is based on the 90% of the weight that is scored. Award interpretation has no section score in either review. The scores are separate from Google and Xero App Store customer ratings. Read our review methodology.

What comes from vendor sources

Both vendors' prices come from their Australian pricing pages, read in November 2026. Feature statuses come from our 46-row feature audit, as at 18 November 2026, 5:27 pm AWST, which checks each capability against vendor documentation.

Security statements are the vendors' own. Xero App Store ratings are a snapshot taken 18 November 2026. Tanda had no Google review listing when we checked on 21 November 2026.

What we could not verify

  • A current price for Tanda Workforce Management with HR (quote-only)
  • A Google rating for Employment Hero (no approved snapshot)
  • Either vendor's own payroll, end to end
  • Penalty and allowance edge cases in Employment Hero's hourly-rate costing without its payroll
  • Where Employment Hero hosts Australian customers' data, its encryption standards, role-based permissions and audit logs
  • Capabilities marked "Not verified" in the feature table

Who wrote this and how to correct it

Written by Steve Harris and edited by Georgia Morgan. RosterElf publishes this page and competes with both vendors. Read our review methodology. If you spot an error, including if you work for Tanda or Employment Hero, contact us and we'll check and correct it.

Our review methodology

Learn how we evaluate workforce management platforms through hands-on testing and verified user feedback.

Feature comparisons are checked against each vendor's public documentation at the time of writing. Assessments of usability, fit and value are our reviewers' opinions, not statements of fact, and products change often. We'd encourage you to trial both platforms and judge for yourself. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.

FAQ

Tanda vs Employment Hero FAQ

  • It depends on the main job. Tanda is the stronger choice when rostering, time and attendance and award-costed timesheets are the daily work. Employment Hero is the stronger choice when HR administration comes first: HR was its highest-scoring area in our review. Our overall scores for each are in the ratings section of this page.
  • We can't say for the package we compare, because Tanda doesn't publish a price for Workforce Management with HR. For 20 staff on monthly billing with payroll staying in Xero or MYOB, Employment Hero HR Essentials with Rostering & Time and Attendance and Chat is A$18.50 per employee, or A$370 a month, excluding GST. Ask Tanda for a written quote and compare it with that total.
  • Tanda maintains templates for common awards and applies penalty and overtime rules to timesheets without Tanda Payroll; other awards are built as custom rules. Employment Hero's award interpretation is tied to Employment Hero Payroll; with payroll kept in Xero or MYOB, its rostering add-on costs shifts from employee hourly rates. In both, the employer stays responsible for correct classifications and pay.
  • Not in its HR plans. Rostering & Time and Attendance is an add-on at A$5 per employee a month (minimum A$50), on top of an HR plan; it is included in the custom-priced Employment Unlimited.
  • Tanda sells Tanda Payroll as one of three modules, alongside Workforce Management and HR. Its only published price, A$12.80 + GST per user a month, is a bundle that includes payroll. You don't need Tanda Payroll to use HR or award interpretation; businesses keeping Xero or MYOB can buy Workforce Management with HR on a custom quote.
  • Yes, by different routes. Tanda exports approved timesheets to Xero and connects directly to MYOB AccountRight Live; we could not confirm a direct MYOB Business connection. Employment Hero uploads approved timesheets to Xero Payroll as drafts that you approve in Xero; for MYOB AccountRight, timesheets don't sync, so you import a timesheet CSV.
  • Employment Hero. HR was its highest-scoring area in our review, with detailed employee profiles, Australian contract and policy templates, and onboarding with e-signatures. Tanda's HR Hub covers qualifications, forms, warnings, incidents and surveys for shift-based teams, but we found little in-product guidance.
  • Other options for Australian shift-based teams include Deputy, Connecteam and RosterElf, the publisher of this page. Our rostering software buying guide compares them on the same criteria, and the comparison hub lists every head-to-head we publish.

Weighing up Tanda and Employment Hero?

RosterElf includes rostering, time and attendance and award pay rules on every plan, priced in AUD, with approved timesheets going to Xero or MYOB. Try it free or book a demo.

Start trial Book a demo

No credit card 4.7 stars from 323 reviews on Google, Xero and G2 30,000+ workplaces