RESEARCH · PUBLIC REVIEWS 2026

Why customers leave Employment Hero common complaints and problems

In about 150 public reviews, reaching support was the most-mentioned topic, while ease of use and the employee app drew the most praise.

Complaints are not departures. These findings identify reasons for dissatisfaction and potential switching. Unless reviewers explicitly state that they cancelled or changed providers, their comments are not counted as confirmed customer departures.

Steve Harris Georgia Morgan Written by Steve Harris·Edited by Georgia Morgan · 10 min read

RosterElf publishes this research and offers competing workforce management software. Public reviews are self-selected and are not a survey of all Employment Hero customers.

Should you stay or switch? How to leave Employment Hero

1
The findings
What about 150 reviews say, and how we read them

Key findings from our analysis

We grouped feedback into recurring themes rather than treating every critical review as the same complaint, and tracked favourable experiences too.

Negative mentions by complaint theme Each bar counts negative theme mentions in a sample of about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026. One review can mention several themes, so a bar counts mentions, not unique reviews, and bars do not add up to the sample. They are not a share of Employment Hero customers, and counts are approximate.
Reaching support about 27 Contracts, cancelling and billing about 24 Implementation and onboarding about 16 HR and payroll as two systems about 12 Payroll accuracy and award rates about 10 Pricing, add-ons and price increases about 9 Rostering and time and attendance about 9 Ease of use about 8 Mobile app about 8 Reporting limits about 5
Mentions in about 150 public reviews, 5 Nov 2026. One review can count in several themes, so mentions don't add up to 150 and aren't a share of Employment Hero customers.
Theme Mentions Direction Negative Positive
about 40 Mostly negative about 27 about 13
about 35 Mostly positive about 8 about 27
about 25 Mostly negative about 24 none (1 mixed)
about 23 Mostly negative about 16 about 7
about 22 Mostly positive about 8 about 14
about 20 Mixed about 12 about 8
about 19 Mixed about 10 about 9
about 15 Mixed about 9 about 6
about 14 Mostly negative about 9 about 5
about 5 Mostly negative about 5 none

These figures describe public-review feedback, not verified cancellation or customer-churn rates.

What reviewers praise

  • Ease of use: a clear, well-labelled interface (about 27 positive mentions)
  • The employee app for shifts, payslips and leave (about 14 positive mentions)
  • HR and payroll in one place (about 8 positive mentions)
What customers like

How we did the research

Sources and what we read
Trustpilot (1- and 2-star pages, the 5-star page and keyword searches), Capterra AU (all visible 1–3-star reviews and the default page), the 6 visible Xero App Store reviews, about 20 G2 snippets, and a few forum threads.
Eligibility
Public reviews and posts about Employment Hero. Competitor-written "reviews", including RosterElf's own pages, were excluded.
Collection dates
Read on 5 Nov 2026. Every quote on this page was checked against its live source on 8 Nov 2026.
Theme coding
Each review was coded against one codebook of themes and marked negative, positive or mixed for each theme it raised.
Reviews with several themes
A review counts once in every theme it mentions, so theme counts overlap and do not add up to the sample.
Counts
Counts are approximate, from our working log, and are shown as "about".

What this research can't tell you

  • How common any issue is among all Employment Hero customers: reviewers choose to write, and strong opinions are over-represented.
  • Whether a reviewer left Employment Hero: most reviews don't say.
  • Trustpilot labels Employment Hero as a company that invites its customers to review, which can shift the mix of recent reviews on that platform.
  • What Reddit users say: Reddit could not be read for this research. Google reviews and full G2 review pages weren't read either.
Full method and codebook

Codebook. Each theme and what it covers:

  • Reaching support: Reaching a person, AI-first help and slow tickets
  • Ease of use: How easy the product is to learn and use day to day
  • Contracts, cancelling and billing: 12-month terms, cancelling, and billing after cancelling
  • Implementation and onboarding: Setup time, training and configuration effort
  • Mobile app: The Employment Hero Work app for staff and managers
  • HR and payroll as two systems: HR and payroll feeling like separate products
  • Payroll accuracy and award rates: Pay run accuracy and award rate handling
  • Pricing, add-ons and price increases: Subscription cost, add-ons and price rises
  • Rostering and time and attendance: Shift management, time capture and clock-in
  • Reporting limits: Report flexibility and custom reports

Departure status. Where a review states it, we separate confirmed departures, reviewers considering leaving, and dissatisfied reviewers who don't mention leaving. We never infer it from a star rating.

How quotes were captured. Capterra AU quotes were copied from the page. Trustpilot and Xero App Store quotes were first captured through a summarising tool, then checked word for word against the live pages on 8 Nov 2026. Trustpilot links point to the filtered listing where the review appeared: search for the reviewer's name on that page.

2
The themes
Support, payroll, pricing, setup, rostering and contracts

Employment Hero customer service and support complaints

About 40 mentions Mostly negative about 27 negative, about 13 positive

From about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026; the reviews quoted here date from 2023–2025.

What reviewers report

Customer support was the most-mentioned theme in the reviews we examined. Some reviewers described difficulty reaching a person, navigating automated assistance or resolving particular tickets. Others praised the speed or helpfulness of the help they received. These accounts describe individual experiences at different times, and they are not proof of current support for every customer.

Critical

"Most of all, not being able to talk to a human. You cannot pick up the phone"

Critical

"The Ask An Expert option has become cumbersome because of the initial AI response"

Travel and tourism, NZ, 11–50 staff Capterra AU · 29 Jan 2025 · Review listing
Positive

"Whenever I have a query, it always get answered within a few minutes."

Counterexamples

About 13 of the support mentions were positive, with reviewers describing quick answers and helpful staff.

What to check: Ask which support channels are available on your plan, how urgent payroll issues are handled, and what onboarding or configuration help is included. Compare the actual service arrangements rather than relying on ratings alone.

Sources

  1. Capterra AU , 6 Dec 2023 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)
  2. Capterra AU , 29 Jan 2025 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)
  3. Capterra AU , 18 Dec 2024 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)

Employment Hero payroll problems reported by reviewers

Payroll accuracy and award rates: About 19 mentions Mixed about 10 negative, about 9 positive

HR and payroll as two systems: About 20 mentions Mixed about 12 negative, about 8 positive

From about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026; the reviews quoted here date from 2021–2026.

What reviewers report

Some reviewers describe frustration with payroll setup, award rates after updates, and timesheets moving between the HR and payroll products. Those reports matter to businesses that need a reliable path from approved hours to pay runs. A reviewer describing an issue is not, by itself, evidence of a confirmed defect affecting other customers.

Critical

"Award rates that are completely incorrect (yes, all possible updates installed)"

Critical

"The integration between the two products - HR and payroll is awful."

Hospital and health care, 51–200 staff Capterra AU · 17 Jan 2021 · Review listing
Positive

"clarification on pitfalls under a very complicated award (SCHADS)"

Counterexamples

This theme is balanced rather than one-sided: about 9 payroll mentions were positive, including praise for help with a complex award (SCHADS), and about 8 reviewers value having HR and payroll in one place.

What to check: Ask for a demonstration using your own award classifications and payroll process. Confirm which Employment Hero products you need, how errors are corrected, and who is responsible for configuration and payroll approval.

Sources

  1. Trustpilot , 8 Apr 2025
  2. Capterra AU , 17 Jan 2021 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)
  3. Trustpilot , 18 Oct 2025

Employment Hero pricing and value concerns

About 15 mentions Mixed about 9 negative, about 6 positive

From about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026; the reviews quoted here date from 2026.

What reviewers report

Pricing complaints are mostly about value for money: whether a business uses enough of the suite, which add-ons it needs, and how the subscription fits its staff numbers, with some reviewers describing price rises over time. A low or high price alone does not establish poor value; the question is the total cost of the features a business needs.

Critical

"Increased from $165 per month to $275/month over three years."

Positive

"Price for features means I will always recommend it for my clients"

Counterexamples

About 6 pricing mentions were positive, mostly about value for the features.

What to check: Compare the complete product configuration, billing terms, minimum commitments and optional services.

Sources

  1. Trustpilot , 8 May 2026
  2. Trustpilot , 22 Mar 2026

Verified plan prices and costs at 10, 20 and 50 staff: Employment Hero review and pricing

Employment Hero implementation and onboarding challenges

About 23 mentions Mostly negative about 16 negative, about 7 positive

From about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026; the reviews quoted here date from 2023–2024.

What reviewers report

Some reviewers report that setting up Employment Hero, learning the system or configuring workflows took more effort than they expected, with several small teams describing weeks of setup and training. Experiences depend on the products used, the organisation and when the review was written.

Critical

"EH is very complicated and takes 40 days to implement"

CEO, hospitality, NZ, 11–50 staff Capterra AU · 7 Mar 2023 · Review listing
Positive

"The platform's implementation process was seamless, thanks to the detailed and easy-to-follow step-by-step guides."

CFO, food production, 51–200 staff Capterra AU · 16 Dec 2024 · Review listing

Counterexamples

About 7 were positive, mostly larger teams describing smooth setups with step-by-step guides.

What to check: Establish who will configure your employee records, pay rules, HR workflows and integrations, and what help is available during implementation. Ask for a realistic project plan for your requirements.

Sources

  1. Capterra AU , 7 Mar 2023 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)
  2. Capterra AU , 16 Dec 2024 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)

Rostering, timesheets and integration frustrations

Rostering and time and attendance: About 14 mentions Mostly negative about 9 negative, about 5 positive

Reporting limits: About 5 mentions Mostly negative about 5 negative, none positive

From about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026; the reviews quoted here date from 2021–2026.

Limited evidence. Rostering and time and attendance has about 14 mentions and Reporting limits has about 5 mentions, fewer than the larger themes, so treat these findings as indicative rather than common.

What reviewers report

For shift-based businesses, the most relevant concerns are the links between rosters, hours actually worked, approvals and payroll. Rostering comes up less often than support or contracts, which suggests many reviewers judge Employment Hero as HR and payroll software. Some reviews mention frustrations with time capture and with fixed, predefined reports.

Critical

"Timekeeping apps (Clock Me In/Workzone) are simply terrible."

Hospital and health care, 51–200 staff Capterra AU · 17 Jan 2021 · Review listing
Positive

"The app for clocking in and out is a particular highlight. It's simple and intuitive"

Critical

"Most of the available reports are predefined, and creating custom reports needs alot of manipulation of excel sheets."

CFO, food production, 51–200 staff Capterra AU · 16 Dec 2024 · Review listing

Counterexamples

About 5 rostering mentions were positive, such as a simple clock-in app. None of the about 5 reporting mentions were positive.

What to check: Test your typical roster, timesheet exceptions, pay rules and payroll transfer with realistic staff scenarios. If rostering is your main requirement, compare specialist workforce platforms on the end-to-end process rather than on feature lists.

Sources

  1. Capterra AU , 17 Jan 2021 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)
  2. Trustpilot , 21 July 2026
  3. Capterra AU , 16 Dec 2024 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)

Rostering hourly staff? Employment Hero vs RosterElf

Employment Hero contracts, minimums and billing complaints

About 25 mentions Mostly negative about 24 negative, none positive, 1 mixed

From about 150 public reviews read 5 Nov 2026; the reviews quoted here date from 2023–2026.

What reviewers report

Reviewers describe being held to 12-month terms after setup stalled or the product went unused, paying for seats they did not use, and being billed after they believed they had cancelled. These are reviewers' accounts of their own agreements; terms differ between customers, so check your own customer agreement.

Critical

"we're locked into a 12 month contract which we have to continue paying even though we haven't used it"

CEO, hospitality, NZ, 11–50 staff Capterra AU · 7 Mar 2023 · Review listing
Mixed

"not have to pay the full year"

Reviewer, Canada (after posting, the reviewer said Employment Hero approved the cancellation) Trustpilot · 2 Mar 2026 · Read the review

Counterexamples

One reviewer said Employment Hero later agreed they would "not have to pay the full year" after they posted. We found no other positive contract mentions.

What to check: Find your minimum term and renewal date in your customer agreement, and diarise the cancellation deadline: under Employment Hero's current terms you must cancel at least 30 days before a renewal date.

Sources

  1. Capterra AU , 7 Mar 2023 (listing filtered by rating; search the quoted words)
  2. Trustpilot , 2 Mar 2026

How to leave Employment Hero: notice, cancelling and your data

3
The other side, and deciding
What users like, whether to stay, and how to leave

What customers like about Employment Hero

Ease of use: About 35 mentions Mostly positive about 27 positive, about 8 negative

Mobile app: About 22 mentions Mostly positive about 14 positive, about 8 negative

What reviewers report

The research also includes plenty of positive feedback. Reviewers describe the interface as clear and easy to learn, value the employee app for shifts, payslips and leave, and like having HR records, onboarding and documents in one place. Some also report helpful support and straightforward setup.

Positive

"The absolute ease in using the interface. Everything is clearly labelled"

HR adviser, electrical manufacturing, 201–500 staff Capterra AU · 13 Dec 2024 · Review listing
Positive

"the employee app is particularly useful, giving colleagues easy access to their shifts, payslips, holidays"

Critical

"Overly complicated. Lacking proper support and a waste of money."

Any balanced assessment should weigh the strengths customers value against the limits other reviewers report. Businesses with extensive HR requirements may have a very different experience from teams mainly focused on weekly rosters and attendance.

Sources

  1. Capterra AU , 13 Dec 2024
  2. Trustpilot , 22 Sept 2026
  3. Capterra AU , 1 Feb 2022

Should you stay with Employment Hero or consider switching?

A complaint doesn't automatically mean switching is the right answer. First work out whether the issue is configuration, a particular plan, a workflow mismatch or an unresolved service experience.

1

Consider staying and resolving it if

  • Employment Hero provides capabilities your business relies on
  • The issue has a documented fix or a clear owner
  • Changing systems would create more risk than it removes
2

Consider comparing alternatives if

  • The product repeatedly fails to meet core requirements
  • The full subscription no longer represents good value
  • Your operational needs have changed
3

Before committing to any replacement, check

  • Data access and export
  • Payroll arrangements and award configuration
  • Contract obligations and notice periods
  • The cost of onboarding another system

Decided to go? How to leave Employment Hero covers notice, cancelling and your data.

How to leave Employment Hero

From Employment Hero's own terms and help centre, read 8 Nov 2026: the General Terms in effect from 15 June 2026. Your customer agreement can set different terms, so check it first. Moving to RosterElf? The step-by-step switching guide covers export, setup and a test pay run.

  1. Check your minimum term

    If you agreed a minimum term, you cannot cancel before it ends. Find it, and your renewal date, in your customer agreement.

  2. Cancel at least 30 days before your renewal date

    After any minimum term, subscriptions renew month to month. Cancel part-way through a month and you pay for that month and the next, with access until the end of the next month. Fees already paid are not refunded. Services such as Managed Payroll need 30 days' written notice under the Service Terms.

  3. Request the cancellation

    The General Terms say you cancel by contacting Employment Hero. For Employment Hero Payroll, its help centre describes: Payroll Settings › Subscription › Speak with our team › Request to cancel your subscription (help article). Keep written confirmation.

  4. Export your data before the end date

    After termination Employment Hero has no obligation to store or give access to your data, and may delete it from the date of termination. Export employee records, documents, leave balances and payroll history first (HR export, payroll export).

  5. Finalise payroll and Single Touch Payroll

    If payroll is moving too, run your final pay run, and finalise Single Touch Payroll or carry each employee's year-to-date figures to your new payroll. Keep pay and time records for seven years, as Fair Work requires.

Plan back from your end date

When What to do
6–8 weeks before
Check your minimum term and renewal date; shortlist and trial a replacement.
At least 30 days before renewal
Request cancellation in writing and keep the confirmation.
2–4 weeks before
Export your data; set up the new system; run one parallel pay run.
End date
Final pay run, Single Touch Payroll handled, final exports checked.
Download the leaving checklist (PDF)

Not legal advice. Terms change; we re-check them when we update this page.

Switching from Employment Hero? Let us know.

We'll help you move across with our complimentary onboarding, and give eligible customers 20% off for your first 12 months when you move from Employment Hero. We'll set up your staff, award pay templates and Xero or MYOB payroll with you.

Offer for eligible new customers switching from Employment Hero: 20% off your RosterElf subscription for the first 12 months of your paid subscription. Send us an Employment Hero invoice from the last three months. One redemption per business; can't be combined with other offers. Available until further notice. Offer terms

Book a switching call

What to look for in an Employment Hero replacement

Choose software based on the problem you need to solve.

If rostering shift workers is the main job

  • Rostering with labour cost visible while you build
  • Time and attendance with clock-in rules for each site
  • Award pay rules applied to every timesheet
  • Payroll-ready timesheets for your payroll software
  • Support during setup

If HR depth is the main job

  • Recruitment and onboarding
  • Employee records, documents and policies
  • Performance and development tools
  • Integrated payroll
  • Security certifications and single sign-on

For a shortlist, see our Employment Hero alternatives in Australia. For a two-product decision, read Employment Hero vs RosterElf.

4
Sources
Where every figure and quote comes from

Sources and transparency

Source What we read Rating shown Read on
Trustpilot
1-star pages 1–2, the 2-star and 5-star pages, and keyword searches (roster, award, price, timesheet, contract, app, payroll, hospitality) 3.9 / 5 (642 reviews) 5 Nov 2026
Capterra AU
All visible 1-, 2- and 3-star reviews, plus the default "most helpful" page 4.4 / 5 (239 reviews) 5 Nov 2026
Xero App Store (AU)
The 6 reviews that are publicly visible, out of 20 3.2 / 5 (20 reviews) 5 Nov 2026
G2
About 20 short testimonial snippets; full review pages were not accessible Not read (review pages not accessible) 5 Nov 2026
Whirlpool and Xero Community
A handful of older threads, with little Employment Hero-specific content – 5 Nov 2026
Author and editor
Steve Harris, edited by Georgia Morgan
Published and reviewed
Published ; research reviewed on
Disclosure
RosterElf publishes this research and makes competing workforce management software.
Employment Hero's response
We haven't asked Employment Hero for comment yet.
Corrections
Spotted an error? Tell us and we'll correct it and date the change.

Next steps

THE PRODUCT

Employment Hero review and pricing

Our hands-on review, verified plan prices and the real cost at 10, 20 and 50 staff.

Employment Hero review and pricing

THE WIDER MARKET

Employment Hero alternatives in Australia

Ten tools compared, from rostering-first platforms to HR and payroll suites.

Employment Hero alternatives in Australia

HEAD TO HEAD

Employment Hero vs RosterElf

For teams rostering hourly staff: rostering, cost, payroll and switching, side by side.

Employment Hero vs RosterElf

READY TO MOVE

Switching from Employment Hero to RosterElf

Contracts, cancelling, data export and payroll migration, step by step.

Switching from Employment Hero to RosterElf
FAQ

Why customers leave Employment Hero: FAQs

Complaints, problems and switching

  • Public reviews describe dissatisfaction with support, contract terms, setup, payroll workflows and pricing. Not every dissatisfied reviewer says they left, so this page treats reviews as reported experiences, not confirmed departures.
  • In about 150 public reviews we read, reaching support was the most-mentioned theme (about 40 mentions), followed by contracts and billing (about 25) and setup (about 23). See the theme table.
  • Some reviewers report difficulty reaching help or resolving tickets, while about 13 support mentions were positive. Support channels can vary by plan, so check the current arrangements for yours.
  • Some public reviews describe payroll-related frustrations, and others praise its payroll and award help. A self-selected review sample cannot show how common an issue is across all customers. Verify your own setup and workflows before deciding.
  • Value depends on the HR, payroll and rostering features you need, the subscription conditions and your staff numbers. For verified prices and costs at 10, 20 and 50 staff, see our Employment Hero review and pricing.