Free casual vs part-time comparison template (Excel)
Compare employment types side by side to decide which is cheaper for your business. Weigh base rate, casual loading, leave and flexibility before you commit to a staff mix.
Casual vs part-time comparison
Excel format (.xlsx) • Ready to download
No signup required. Works with Excel and Google Sheets.
This casual vs part-time comparison template is a general decision-support tool only. It is not financial, tax or legal advice, does not calculate wages or entitlements, and does not replace award interpretation or payroll software. Always verify rates and obligations against the relevant Modern Award with Fair Work and the ATO. It does not constitute legal, HR, or professional advice and should not be relied on as a substitute for advice specific to your business, workforce, or circumstances.
What's in this template
A structured side-by-side comparison framework
Employment type
Compare casual, part-time and full-time side by side in their own columns.
Typical weekly hours
Record the expected hours per week for each option you are weighing up.
Leave entitlements
Note the paid-leave differences — pro-rata for part-time, none for casual.
Loading notes
Capture casual loading considerations (typically the 25% on-cost) against each type.
Flexibility
Weigh scheduling flexibility and how predictable the hours need to be.
Decision notes
A free-text column to document your reasoning so the choice is defensible later.
Example comparison
Use this framework to compare factors side by side. For exact dollar figures, pair it with our cost calculator.
| Factor | Casual | Part-time |
|---|---|---|
| Typical hours | Variable, as needed | Set hours each week |
| Leave entitlements | No paid leave | Pro-rata leave |
| Loading | Casual loading applies (~25%) | No loading |
| Flexibility | High for employer | Set schedule |
How to compare casual vs part-time cost in Excel
Four steps to see which is cheaper
1. List the demand pattern
Note whether the hours are ongoing and predictable or fluctuating. Steady, ongoing work points to part-time; peaks and unpredictable cover point to casual.
2. Add the base rate vs loading
Enter the award base hourly rate, then add the casual loading (usually 25%) in the casual column. Part-time keeps the base rate but accrues paid leave.
3. Compare weekly totals
Use a simple =hours*rate column for each type to compare like for like. The casual column shows the loaded rate; the part-time column shows base plus a leave allowance.
4. Record the decision
Part-time is usually cheaper long-term for consistent hours; casual wins for variable demand you only pay per hour. Note your reasoning in the decision column.
Prefer instant numbers? The casual vs part-time cost calculator does the loaded-rate maths for you. And before you compare, make sure you’re on the right rates with our guide to finding which award applies.
Who uses this template
For businesses making staffing decisions
Hospitality
Decide the staff mix between regular shifts and on-call cover for your venue.
Retail
Plan floor staff employment types around steady trade versus peak periods.
Aged care
Compare staffing for care teams where consistent rosters often favour part-time.
Whichever mix you choose, you’ll need to set steady patterns and pay people right — see our guide to calculating leave entitlements for your part-time and permanent staff.
Need accurate, award-aware labour costing?
A spreadsheet is great for weighing up the options, but it won't keep up with award rates, penalties and loadings as they change. RosterElf shows real-time labour costs as you build rosters and feeds approved hours straight into payroll, so casual & part-time costs are always based on the live rates — not last year's numbers.
Payroll & award guides
Get the rates and rules right before you decide
Casual loading explained
How the 25% casual loading works, what it replaces, and how it affects your cost comparison.
Read the articleHow to handle casual conversion
A step-by-step guide to moving eligible casuals onto permanent part-time or full-time terms.
Read the guideCasual vs part-time cost calculator
Work out the real loaded cost difference instantly — the interactive companion to this template.
Open the calculatorRelated templates
Explore more free award & payroll templates
Leave & super tracker
Track accrued leave and super for your part-time and permanent staff.
Get the templatePayroll preparation template
Collect and check every payroll input before you run pay.
Get the templateAll award & payroll templates
Browse the full free award and payroll template library.
Browse allCasual vs part-time comparison FAQ
-
It depends on the work pattern. Part-time is generally cheaper for consistent, ongoing hours because part-timers don’t receive the casual loading — the base wage plus pro-rata leave usually costs less than a continuous 25% premium. Casual is cheaper for fluctuating or unpredictable demand and peak cover, since you only pay for hours worked with no paid-leave liability. Model both with our casual vs part-time cost calculator.
-
Casuals receive a casual loading — usually 25% under most Modern Awards — on top of the base hourly rate, instead of paid leave, notice of termination and redundancy pay. So a casual on a 25% loading is paid 1.25× the base rate that an equivalent part-time employee receives. See casual loading explained and what defines a casual employee.
-
Put each employment type in its own column, enter the award base rate and expected weekly hours, then add the casual loading to the casual column and a pro-rata leave allowance to the part-time column. A simple =hours*rate formula gives you a like-for-like weekly total. This template comes pre-built with those columns, or follow the four steps above. For exact award-aware rates use payroll software with award interpretation.
-
No. This template is for structured comparison and decision notes — it does not calculate wages, costs or entitlements. For an instant cost calculation, use our casual vs part-time cost calculator; for payroll-grade figures, use software with built-in payroll integration.
Before you download
General information only — not legal advice
This document is a general HR template provided for informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and may not reflect the latest changes in legislation or apply to every workplace situation. RosterElf Pty Ltd and the template provider accept no liability for any loss arising from reliance on this document. Users should seek independent legal advice and customise the template to ensure it complies with all relevant laws, awards and workplace requirements.